What do you do when what you’ve always done doesn’t work anymore? I’m confused, lonely, and feel extremely guilty. I used to have all the answers. Students used to flock to events and programs. That’s not the case anymore and I’m now left with the nagging questions about whether it’s my incompetence or something cultural. I do know this: something is broken. Maybe it’s me, maybe it’s youth ministry models, or maybe it’s all of the above. Gone are the days when churches can simply hire a youth director to run a program and expect large flocks of students with nothing else to do on Sundays or Wednesdays to show up, embrace the gospel, and become committed disciples. I know things have to change, but more times than not I have no idea what my job is supposed to look like. I question what I’m doing and I question whether I’m even the best person to be doing it. Would my church, and more importantly, the Youth of my church be better served by someone else?
What is youth ministry? Is there ONE definition to answer that question? What do we do with students that have now grown up in a totally digital era? Even the poorest of the students I encounter have computers, video games, cell phones, and TV. How do you “attract” that? Pizza? Crazy relays? Cool acronyms? I think not!
What is “Deep Biblical Teaching”? If the answer to our youth ministry quandary is that our students are hungry for more depth in teaching, why don’t they flock to the “Big” church service? I hear it said that our teaching needs to be deep, but also on their level. Seriously, what does that mean? Is it deep, or is it kind of deep? Do you remember more than a handful of sermons you heard as a teen? Why do we continue to believe in the evangelical world that the “cure all” is a lesson or sermon when time and time again it is proven that the teacher/learner model is one of the least effective? If I wanted to be in the business of imparting biblical information I would have taken a job as a professor at a Christian school.
Daily I take into account the diversity of personalities, race, financial status, geographic location, and family life of the students God has sent to our ministry. Am I the only one thinking about this? We are a church is filled with the same diversity. Yet, we offer a ton of different ways for folks to deepen their souls, find relationship, and join the mission because we know that no one program meets the needs of every person. At some point we have to state our vision and purpose clearly, narrow our programming to best fit that vision and purpose, and move forward the best we can.
The enormity of the responsibility I have been given in Youth Ministry is very real to me. I don’t know how long I can keep going but the thought of giving up and walking away terrifies me even more. Too much is at stake! Too many students need Jesus! I’m willing to fight this fight – regardless of the consequences. Another thing I know: if we go backwards in student ministry we will continue to ask these same questions about numbers, depth, and programming instead of moving forward with ideas and practices that will help today’s students deepen their souls, find relationship, and join the mission.
Am I the only one that's lost out here? Fix me if you can!
Evolving Faith 2019
5 years ago